THE
ORANGE
HUB
EPF vs NPS: Which is Better for Retirement Planning?

Planning for retirement is essential for ensuring stability, and choosing the appropriate investment instrument is crucial for shaping your retirement fund. In India, the Employees’ Provident Fund (EPF) and National Pension System (NPS) are the two preferred options for retirement savings. Each of them has distinct features, advantages, and regulations suited to different needs. This article focuses on NPS vs EPF, comparing their features to help you determine which one aligns better with your retirement planning objectives.
What is EPF and NPS?
The Employees’ Provident Fund (EPF) is a government-supported savings scheme designed for individuals across India. Established under the Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act of 1952, this scheme is overseen by the Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO). The primary objective of the EPF is to provide employees with a lump sum payout upon reaching retirement age or discontinuing employment.
Read More - What is National Pension Scheme
Key Differences Between NPS and EPF
Here is a table to decide between NPS vs EPF which is better.
Feature |
NPS |
EPF |
Investment of Contributions |
Two modes: Active and Auto. Active choice allows up to 50% in equity. Auto choice adjusts based on age. Government employees' contributions have only 15% equity exposure. |
Invests in government securities, PSU bonds, and deposits. Returns are independent of market conditions. Compounding interest is paid even if bonds and securities have flexible returns. |
Rate of Returns |
Varies with market conditions and investment ratio. Example returns: 2012-2013: 9.76%, 2013-2014: 5.37%, 2014-2015: 19.63%, Overall: 10.35%. |
Average returns range from 8.00% - 8.50% p.a. |
Liquidity and Withdrawals |
Withdrawals at 60, with 40% invested in an annuity. Partial withdrawals allowed if 80% is in an annuity. |
Withdrawals are allowed for specific purposes like medical treatment, home loans, and education, with limits based on salary multiples. |
Tax Benefits and Deductions |
Contributions up to Rs. 2 Lakh deductible under Sections 80C and 80CCD(1B). Only Rs. 50,000 can be claimed separately under Section 80CCD(1B). Withdrawals except annuities are taxable. |
Contributions, interest earned, and withdrawals are tax-free under Section 80C. No additional benefits beyond 80C deductions. |
Deciding Between EPF and NPS
Here are some key considerations when weighing the options:
1. Risk Preference
EPF provides returns with minimal risk, making it suitable for cautious investors seeking stability and assured returns. On the other hand, NPS involves investments tied to the market, which can potentially yield higher returns but also come with certain risks. Individuals who are comfortable with market fluctuations and are looking for growth opportunities might prefer NPS.
2. Tax Benefits
NPS allows for an additional deduction of Rs. 50,000 under Section 80CCD(1B). For those focused on maximising tax savings, NPS could be an attractive option due to its higher deduction limits. However, the tax-free aspect of EPF withdrawals after five years of service is also a significant benefit.
3. Investment Time Frame
EPF is suitable for long-term savings with a focus on stable returns, while NPS is more fitting for individuals with an investment horizon who can handle market fluctuations. Younger individuals with many years left in their working life may find the potentially higher returns of NPS advantageous.
4. Access to Funds
EPF allows withdrawals for various needs, providing liquidity during emergencies and personal milestones. In contrast, NPS has stricter withdrawal regulations that prioritise building a retirement fund. If flexibility in accessing funds is crucial, EPF might be the better choice.
5. Retirement Objectives
Consider your retirement objectives and income needs. NPS offers the benefit of a pension through annuity purchases, ensuring stability during retirement. If you prioritise having a steady income after retiring, NPS might be better suited to your requirements.
Conclusion
In the comparison between NPS and EPF, there is no one-size-fits-all solution. Both EPF and NPS offer distinct advantages that cater to various financial needs and risk preferences. Ultimately, choosing between EPF and NPS depends on your goals, risk appetite, and retirement strategy. Many people opt for a combination of both to leverage the strengths of each plan and build a well-rounded retirement portfolio.
By considering these aspects, you can develop a retirement strategy that ensures financial stability and peace of mind in your later years.
Scroll to top