Sawal Jawab Sawal Jawab

Definition of NRI, ROR, RNOR
FEMA definition of NRI
Taxability Depending upon Status
Types of NRI-related Accounts
Bank Accounts Operated by PoA
Taxability of NRE/FCNR Interest in the Host Country
Taxability of NRE & FCNR for Returning NRI's
PPF Contributions Limited to Rs. 60,000
Eligibility for RFC
Returning NRI's can keep Assets Abroad
Tax under Special Provisions
Persons Deputed Abroad
Before becoming NRI
Import of FE
Repatriation of Sale Proceeds of Shares
20% Tax with Indexation v 10% without
Wealth Tax
Procedure for Gifting
Avoid Gifts
Purchase of House Property
House Purchased in Wife's Name
House Purchased from Loan
Repatriability of Income from House Property
Foreign Nationals Working in India
PIO Card is not Much Useful
Stock option
Life Insurance & Repatriability
Exchange Risk
Casual Approach
Forex Availability to Residents
Foreigners & FE
Prudent to File Returns in India
Tax Haven
Post your Sawal
Recent Sawals
Acronyms

 


  01: Definition of NRI, ROR, RNOR

These are 3 statutes under ITA --- 1. Resident and Ordinarily Resident (ROR) 2. Resident but Not Ordinarily Resident (RNOR) and 3. Non-Resident Indian (NRI).

The act defines Resident as follows :

A Resident is one who during a Financial Year (FY), which is from April to March,  satisfies any one of the following 2 basic conditions :

He is in India for at least

  a) 182 days in the FY OR
  b) 365 days out of the preceding 4 FYs AND 60 days in the FY.

The stay in India need not be continuous.

Most people going abroad for a job for the first time will have the status of Resident since they will be covered by the 'b' clause above. To help such persons acquire NRI status the following provision is added.

If an Indian citizen leaves India in any year for the purpose of employment, the 60 days in clause 'b' is to be replaced by 182 days.

In other words, they will be treated as Residents only if they are in India for 182 days or more in the current FY.

This provision is also made applicable to the crew of an Indian ship. The crew of a foreign ship is treated as having left India for employment. Earlier, the crew of an Indian ship was not treated as having left India.

To facilitate NRIs who come to India on vacation or for short trips (business or otherwise) ---

If an Indian citizen or a person of Indian origin who is out of India, comes to visit India, the period of '60 days' is to be replaced by 182 days (thanks to FA94). This period was 90 days upto AY 89-90 and 150 days upto AY 94-95.

Now Residents can be of two types ---

1. Resident and Ordinarily Resident (R&OR): A person who satisfies BOTH the below mentioned conditions is said to be an R&OR.
  a) He is  Resident in India in 9 out of last 10 years OR
  b) He is in India for period/s amounting in all to 730 days or more out of the 7 preceding years.
2.

An individual who satisfies only one or none of the above two conditions will be treated as a Resident but Not Ordinarily Resident(RNOR)

Any person who does not satisfy even one of the above basic conditions is termed as Non-Resident. In other words, a person who is not a Resident is a Non-Resident.

Please note that a person who is an NRI for at least 2 successive years preceding his arrival in India (which is the situation in most of the cases) enjoys the status of RNOR for the next 9 years.


  02: FEMA definition of NRI

FEMA defines 'a person outside India' and ITA defines NRI, though the term 'NRI' is used for both the purposes loosely.

Person Resident in India is ---

1 A person residing in India for more than 182 days during the course of the preceding financial year but does not include,
  A) a person who has gone out of India or who stays outside India, in either case
    i) for or on taking up employment outside India, or
    ii) for carrying on outside India a business or vocation outside India, or
    iii) for any other purpose, in such circumstances as would indicate his intention to stay outside India for an uncertain period;
  B) i) a person who has come to or stays in India, in either case, otherwise than
      a) for or on taking up employment in India, or
      b) for carrying on in India a business or vocation in India, or
      c) for any purpose, in such circumstances as would indicate his intention to stay in India for an uncertain period;
    ii) any person or body corporate registered or incorporated in India,
    iii) an office, branch or agency in India owned or controlled by a person resident outside India,
    iv) an office, branch or agency outside India owned or controlled by a person resident in India;
2 A Person Resident Outside India means a person who is not resident in India.
3 This definition is identical to one in FERA and has tried to delete the precepts of citizenship and 'Persons of Indian Origin'.
4 ITA defines the period as 182 days or more whereas FEMA defines it as more than 182 days.
         

  03: Taxability Depending upon Status

ROR has to pay tax on his total global income which includes all income from whatever source derived.

RNOR also has to pay tax on his global income except on the income which accrues or arises outside India, unless it is derived from a business controlled in or a profession set up in India.

NRI is not at all liable to tax in respect of income accruing or arising outside India, even if it is remitted to India. He is liable to pay tax only in respect of income received or deemed to be received in India or which accrues or arises or is deemed to accrue or arise in India.

Salary or pension received in India from abroad by a non-resident is taxable in India as income received in India. However, if the pension is received by or on behalf of the employee in a foreign country and later on remitted to India, it will be exempt from tax in India since it is not treated as income received in India.

 

 04: Types of NRI-related Accounts

'Residents Outside India' which covers NRIs, can own several accounts. Non Resident External (NRE) and Foreign Currency Non Resident (FCNR) are with repatriation rights (NRNR --- Non Resident Non Repatriable --- account which was available earlier was without repatriation rights and used to earn higher rate of interest). The NRE account is maintained in INR and the FCNR in foreign currencies. All these accounts can be opened and maintained by remitting funds through normal banking channels in freely convertible currency from abroad or by transfer of funds from NRE or FCNR accounts. The interest is tax-free in India as long as the account holders remains an NRI.

The non-repatriable account that NRIs can maintain is called the Non-Resident Ordinary (NRO). This is akin to the savings bank account that Residents have. The NRO account enables handling investments and income arising out of Indian sources before the account holder became an NRI and also the non-repatriable income.

As soon as a Resident  becomes a NRI, his Resident accounts as such should be converted to NRO accounts.


05: Bank Accounts Operated by PoA

Typically a NRI finds it difficult to operate bank accounts in India because of the distance. He may authorise a trusted person with PoA (Power of Attorney). PoA is to be executed on a stamp paper of proper denomination and can cover many areas other than bank operations only. It is better if one gets it drafted by a lawyer. If the NRI wishes to limit it only for bank operations, a LoA (Letter of Authority) will be enough. The banks will provide the forms for LoA.

The holder of the LoA can issue cheques to third parties for bonafide reasons. He should avoid withdrawal in cash. The amounts withdrawn can be construed as his income for services rendered and would be taxable in his hands. There should be an express agreement between the NRI and the holder of LOA in writing that the cash withdrawals are gifts to the LoA holder.


 06: Taxability of NRE / FCNR Interest in the Host Country

The interest on NRE and FCNR is free from Indian taxes, whether an NRI operates the account directly from his host country or from India. However, he will have to check on the taxability of this income in his host country. It is a known fact that some of the branches of foreign banks have been asked to submit a list of the NRE and FCNR account holders. Fortunately, the governments of the foreign countries cannot make any such demand on the Indian banks.

 


  07: Taxability of NRE & FCNR for Returning NRIs

Sec. 10(4ii) exempts interest on NRE in the hands of an individual provided such an individual is a person resident outside India as defined by Sec. 2(q) of FERA. FEMA has replaced FERA but the ITA continues to refer to FERA.

On maturity, an ex-NRI cannot renew these accounts. In respect of interest on FCNR, it is exempt u/s 10(15fa) in the hands of an NRI or RNOR until its maturity. The NRE interest, however, becomes taxable from the date of arrival to India permanently.

You are allowed a reasonable time before you inform all the companies and banks about the change in your status wherever you have your investments.  What is reasonable time within which you should inform the bank about the change of your status? I strongly feel that a period of 3 months is a reasonable assumption. This was the period allowed by RIFEE (Returning Indians Foreign Exchange Entitlement scheme) before it was abolished.

You are allowed to continue with your all NRI-related bank accounts, including NRE FDs, until their maturity. Thereafter, you will have to convert the NRE and FCNR into repatriable RFC accounts or non-convertible ordinary bank accounts. The interest on NRE would become taxable and it would be from the date of your return, irrespective of the date when you inform the bank about the change of the status. The interest on FCNR, however, is tax-free if you become an  RNOR after your return.


  08: PPF Contributions Limited to Rs. 60,000
Contributions made by an individual to his own account, accounts of his minor children, HUF of which he is a member and AOP is limited to Rs. 60,000. If one exceeds this and the irregularity comes to the notice of the accounts office, it will return the excess contribution without any interest to the account holder.

 

 


  09: Eligibility for RFC

A person who has been Resident Outside India for a continuous period of not less than one year (exclusive of short visits to India for holidays or on health grounds) who returns to India permanently, is required to close his non-resident related bank accounts either immediately or at their maturity and convert their foreign currency into INR. If he desires to keep the entitlement to the forex for his use in future, he can use RFC. He can take these funds back if and when he once again goes abroad. Remittances abroad can be made for some specified and bonafide reasons. Those who have a stay of less than a year and wish to open RFC Account require RBI permission (Form-RFC).

This account was (note the past tense) useful for availability of foreign exchange to the account holder for some specific predefined purposes. Now, thanks to the process of liberalisation, RFC has outlived its utility. Following are the reasons :

1 Forex is liberally made available to the Residents when it is needed for bonafide reasons.
2 The interest on RFC is low.
3 Tax is deducted at source @30.6% on this interest, though it is tax-free in the hands of RNORs. Possibly, the reason for application of TDS is to relieve the banks the responsibility of ascertaining whether the account holder is an RNOR or not.
4 Now NRIs are allowed to keep their assets abroad.
5 It is possible to earn around 10%+ tax-free interest from other sources in India. (Read FAQ33).
6 RBI allows the residents to buy foreign exchange for various needs. The limits on entitlements are sufficiently high.
I strongly feel that RFC has now become an useless utility.
       

  10: Returning NRIs can Keep Assets Abroad
As per FEMA Sec. 6(4), any person who was continuously resident outside India for at least one year has, even after his return to India permanently, been granted the general permissions to ÄÄ
1 maintain and operate his foreign currency accounts with banks abroad;
2 hold, transfer or dispose off their other foreign currency assets such as shares, securities, life insurance policies, immovable property outside India and even his investments in businesses outside India (in case the NRI wants to retain his links abroad through employment, business or vocation outside India);
3 enjoy complete freedom for utilisation of all his foreign currency assets including the freedom to gift or settle these assets to anybody in the world;
4 earn and retain abroad even pension and retirement benefits;
5 earn, hold or dispose of or invest in any manner he deems it fit, even incomes on his foreign currency assets;
6 make any payments or investments abroad provided the payments and the cost of such fresh investments and any subsequent payments required are met exclusively out of such assets.

There is no need of any approval from RBI even after the NRI becomes, after his return, a person resident in India.

This general permission will not apply in respect of any asset received after becoming a resident by way of gift or inheritance from abroad. Similarly, the benefit is not available on earnings from employment secured subsequent to the return. If the ex-NRI wishes to retain such assets abroad or liquidate them and deposit the money in an RFC account, he has to apply for permission from RBI.


  11: Tax Under Special Provisions
NRIs and PIOs enjoy 'Special Provisions' u/s 115C dealing with tax on incomes from certain Foreign Exchange Assets (FEA) which the assessee has acquired, purchased or subscribed to in convertible foreign exchange :
1 Shares in an Indian company.
2 Debentures (convertible as well as non-convertible) issued by an Indian company.
3 Deposits with an Indian public limited company.
4 Securities of the central government.

Any income which is derived from FEA is connoted as 'investment income'. The definition of FEA does not include bank deposits! But mostly, these can be brought under the purview of the provisions through the above mentioned 'deposits with an Indian company'.  All the banks, i) of which shares are listed in the stock market (e.g. SBI, HDFC bank, ICICI Bank) ii) banks which continue to be Indian Companies (e.g. United Western Bank Ltd.) and iii) nationalised banks which were originally incorporated as Indian Companies before nationalisation (e.g., Canara Bank, Bank of Baroda) are eligible for the concessions of special provisions.

It is evident that none of the foreign banks, or co-operative banks are eligible for this facility, a point which dawns on the NRIs only when it is too late.

Once the NRI returns to India permanently, he can continue to be covered by these provisions until the FEA are liquidated.

Salient Features

  • The NRI is given the option in respect of investment income to be governed either by the special or the general provisions of the ITA. This option can be exercised by expressing his desire appropriately in the return of income. He is free to change his mind every year and decide for each FY as to whether he wants to opt for the special provisions or not.
  • If the individual opts for the special provisions, his investment income is taxed at a flat rate of 20%. No deduction under Chapter VI-A of ITA, i.e., u/s Sec. 80L, 80G, etc., (comprehensive list given at the end of the chapter) is allowed. However, the benefit of tax rebate u/s 88 is available, Therefore, an NRI can contribute Rs. 60,000 to PPF, LIC, etc., and further Rs. 20,000 to instruments of infrastructure companies and save tax amounting to Rs. 16,000. He is free to contribute the entire Rs. 80,000 to infrastructure. An NRI is not eligible for the rebate of senior citizens u/s 88B or junior female citizens u/s 88C, but once the individual becomes a Resident, (RNOR is a Resident with special privileges) he can claim the benefits of the rebates.
  • In case the assessee has other taxable income in addition to investment income, the other income will form a separate block, and taxed at the rates applicable to the residents as per the general provisions.
  • Return of income need not be filed if tax is deducted at source correctly (Sec. 115G).
  • In order to avoid delays in remitting the sale proceeds of FEA, Sec. 204 (iia) authorises an AD to deduct tax if it is not a short-term gain and remit the balance to the NRI or credit it to his NRE account, without the requirement of any NOC from the Department.
  • U/s 115F, long-term capital gains on transfer of FEA are nohe rupee slipping heavily and the banks going bankrupt.

Now, let us turn our attention to the risk of 'loss of opportunity t charged to tax if the net consideration is reinvested either in FEA or in NRE accounts, within 6 months from the date of such transfer.

Continuation of Special Provisions

When an NRI becomes a resident assessee, the concession of the Special Provisions continue to apply.

Note that the status of residentship is applicable for income tax purposes, for the entire financial year. In the case of FEMA, in most of the cases, the residentship changes from the day an individual goes abroad or returns to India permanently. Therefore, if you are an NRI, even after you return to India permanently, by virtue of your being outside India for 182 days, the income is free from tax and you can start claiming the benefits of these special provisions from 1st April of the year when you become an RNOR and even after you become a full-fledged resident, unless you have encashed or transferred these deposits. This concession is not applicable after the deposits are liquidated or renewed.

To Be or not to Be

An NRI has the option of selecting either the flat tax rate of 20% or the normal rate of tax. What should he opt for? Well, let us see.

Suppose an NRI's entire income of Rs. 2,87,000 is investment income from FEA.

If he opts for normal rates,

Gross Income         Rs. 2,87,000
less : u/s 80L         Rs.      9,000
                             Rs.  2,78,000
Tax Thereon*                                      Rs. 57,400
If he opts for the Special Provisions
Tax @20% on Rs. 2,87,000                 Rs. 57,400
* Plus surcharge of 5%

Obviously, it will be advantageous to opt for normal rates if his gross 'investment income' is less than
Rs. 2,87,000 and for special rates if the income is more than that level.


  12: Persons Deputed Abroad

Allowances granted to cover expenses incurred wholly, necessarily and exclusively in performance of office duties are not taxable. It would be illogical to impose any tax on such allowances. Some unscrupulous employers used to take undue advantage of this and dole out allowances far in excess of what is necessary. Therefore, it is logical to tax any savings effected out of this allowance. Such savings obtains the colour and character of salary income.

In a few cases, the individual gets some payment directly from the foreign company, over and above the salary paid in India by the Indian employer. If there is an employer-employee relationship between the individual and the foreign employer, this payment is tax-free in India. It may be taxed in the host country and the amount is dependent upon the tax provisions of the country.

If the said relationship does not exist, the foreign payment is also taxable in India since its nexus is of Indian origin. If an income is taxable in both the countries, it is eligible for the benefit of DTAA between the two countries. DTAA is available on www.incometaxdelhi.nic.in.

Now let us turn to the right to hold NRE / FCNR accounts in India. This is governed by FEMA. Yes, the individual is abroad but his employment is not. Therefore, he is not a Resident Outside India. He is not entitled to open NRE / FCNR accounts which are related with forex. Obviously, a Resident does not normally earn any foreign exchange, and therefore, what will he do with the NRI-related accounts?

However, once his stay outside India is over 182 days in a FY, he will become a Resident Outside India, in the next FY, thanks to the FEMA definition. It is possible for him to open the NRI-related accounts after the first financial year.

If the individual earns any side income by way of moonlighting assignments, the taxability of this income is dependent upon his residential status for income tax. It is tax-free in India if he is an NRI and taxable if he is a Resident.

This is theory. In practice, I am aware that some of the banks allow the deputies (and even students!) to open and operate the NRI-related accounts and this was the situation even during the old FERA regime. They are quite keen to have accounts earning forex and are not too careful. The phrase, 'for or on taking up employment outside India' is interpreted broadly and extrapolated to even the deputies. Note that when a person is allowed by a bank to open such accounts, the Department normally assumes that this is in accordance with FEMA. You need not worry much for having breached the law. The bank (AD) is more responsible than you.


 13: Before becoming NRI

You are required to inform all your banks and also all the companies where you have investments about the change in your status. The banks will re-designate your accounts as NRO.

It is also necessary to inform all the companies whose shares you hold, and UTI / MFs about change in your status. In practice, most of the NRIs do not follow these rules and do not face any problems because the regulatory mechanism of the income tax department is not yet in place. Obviously, a few are apprehended and I hope you are not one of them. Realise that you do not gain anything by not following the rules.

When you inform a company about your changed status, it will inform the RBI, if necessary, to enable it to keep a track of the percentage investment of individual NRIs and also all the NRIs put together in a company. There are some specified limits, beyond which, the investments are not permitted.

You will also start filing your tax returns in your new NRI status. True, if the Indian income is below the taxable threshold, there is no need to file the returns but it is prudent to do so for maintaining the continuity.

Even after you become an NRI, you are free to deal with all your investments and assets you held prior to becoming an NRI any which way you desire. The only restriction is that the original corpus is non-repatriable. Fortunately, income arising out of these assets is repatriable if you have paid proper taxes thereon.

It would be advisable to give a power of attorney or letter of authority to anyone of your choice to operate your NRE bank account. Withdrawals can be effected from this account for local disbursements, investment in units of UTI, some MF schemes, government securities, etc. In the case of NRO or NRSR, you can have a Resident as a joint holder. The maturity proceeds of PPF, KVPs, NSCs, etc., can be credited freely to your NRO account by the joint holder.

Your PPF will have to be run until its maturity. In the unlikely event of your Indian income becoming taxable, you can use it to save taxes. On the other hand, if your Indian income is not likely to come into the tax net, even in the distant future, you need not contribute even the Rs. 100 and let the account become discontinued. I strongly recommend you to keep it alive so that you will be entitled to make partial withdrawals and earn higher interest from other sources in place of PPF.

Give some thought to surrendering your LIC policies unless the maturity date is in the near future. If you are going abroad permanently along with your family, repatriability of the payment made by LIC on your demise may be problematic if the family decides to continue to stay abroad.

Since your Indian income would have gone down substantially, you will be in a good position to withdraw from your NSS account. If the total income inclusive of NSS withdrawals is less than the minimum chargeable to tax a resident individual can file Form 15-I in duplicate with the post office declaring that the tax payable for the year is nil and therefore, no tax should be deducted at source. For some strange reasons, once you become an NRI, you are not allowed the privilege of filing Form 15-I. If however, the income crosses the minimum level because of NSS withdrawals, you may use your PPF account to bring the tax liability down to nil level.


  14: Import of FE

There is no limit on the foreign exchange an NRI can carry with him while visiting India. There is no need to make a declaration to the customs authorities at the airport (or seaport) if at any one time the value of foreign currency notes brought does not exceed US$ 5,000 and the aggregate value of the foreign currency up to
US$ 2,000 or its equivalent provided the forex was acquired as permitted.


  15: Repatriation of Sale Proceeds of Shares
An NRI should authorise only one branch of only one bank in India for the portfolio management scheme. Specific power of attorney should be granted in favour of the bank, to carry out the various formalities. The dividend is tax-free and repatriable. When the shares are sold, the capital originally invested along with the capital gains thereon can be repatriated only after the tax thereon is paid and a no-objection certificate is obtained from the Department. Incidentally, the NRIs enjoy concessional rate of 10% on long-term capital gains earned on sale of shares and securities. They also enjoy protection against exchange risk.

  16: 20% Tax with Indexation v 10% without

NRIs are allowed 10% tax on LT gains arising out of only listed shares and securities. The same privilege is also applicable to units of UTI/MFs. The intention is to provide the NRIs protection against the exchange risk but not against inflation. On all the rest of the assets, such as residential flats, land, jewellery, etc., the rate is 20% with the protection against inflation through cost inflation index.

In the case of equities and units, the Residents can opt for 10% tax without indexation or 20% with indexation but not the NRIs.

Then again, it is true that the NRIs stand protected against the slippage of the Rupee but what if it stops slipping? They should have also been offered the privilege of opting between 10% and 20%.

This 'at par with NRIs' business appears to have turned the tables.


  17: Wealth Tax

No one need worry much about it any longer. The tax is levied only on 'unproductive assets' and therefore investments in shares, debentures, UTI, MFs, etc., are exempt from wealth tax. One house or part of a house (residential or otherwise) or a plot of land not exceeding 500 square metres, belonging to an individual (NRI or otherwise) or an HUF is exempt from wealth tax. Jewellery, cars, aeroplanes, yachts, etc., are taxed but then again, the minimum threshold of wealth tax is as high as Rs. 15 lakhs. Above that limit, the tax is as low as 1%.


  18: Procedure for Gifting

Gifts by NRIs in foreign exchange was always tax-free. Now that the Gift Tax Act has been abolished, all gifts, made by anyone, NRI or otherwise, through foreign exchange or Indian assets, are free from gift tax. All that is required is an offer by the donor and acceptance thereof by them. To safeguard against any hassles, the donee should request the donor for a gift and then the donor should remit the amount to the donee. Alternatively, the donor can offer the gift. In either case, it is necessary for the donee to accept the gift in writing (maybe through a thank you note).  Only then it would be considered as a gift in India.

It is better to prepare a gift deed and get it registered (with related plus stamp duty) but such a precaution is normally needed in the case of high-value gifts, particularly related with real estate.

However, take note of the fact that the Department has a right to inquire into the genuineness of the gift to ensure that it is not a payment made for any havala or smuggling transaction.


  19: Avoid Gifts

Gift Tax Act stands abolished now. There is no gift tax, either donor or donee-based, on gifts. There is no clubbing provision in respect of gifts to major children. It is applicable only to minors. All the same, I would recommend that you avoid giving a gift to your children, unless there are some need-based reasons to do so.

Before the GTA was abolished, aggregate gifts over Rs. 30,000 in a financial year was taxable at the penal rate of 30% and therefore, it was a wise strategy to give a gift up to that limit and build up a corpus for the children (and also spouse). When the child needed a large sum for some specific need such as education or marriage or start up of a business or profession, the money would be readily available. This strategy avoided the need to give a gift of a large sum when needed. Now that you can give need-based gifts as and when it arises, there is no need to build a corpus for your child and take the risk of the child running away (and worst, your wife eloping) with the money.

There is a residual advantage in giving gifts. The income earned  on the gifted corpus by your minor children is taxed in your hands. Incidentally, the spouse is treated as a minor and the income is clubbable. The only difference is that in the case of minor children the entire income, with a paltry exemption of Rs. 1,500  per year per child (more, the merrier), is taxable in your hands whereas in the case of the spouse, the income on gifted corpus is clubbable. Once you have paid the tax, on this first-stage interest, and if your wife invests the money somewhere, the income thereon is not clubbed in your hands.


  20: Purchase of House Property

All persons, whether resident in India or outside  India, who are citizens of Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Afghanistan, China, Iran, Nepal or Bhutan, require prior permission of the RBI for acquiring or transferring any immovable property in India.

An ROI who has been permitted by the RBI to establish a branch or office or place of business in India (excluding a liaison office) can acquire a property which is  necessary for or incidental to the activity.  A declaration, in prescribed  form (IPI), is required to be filed with the RBI, within 90 days of the acquisition of the property.

An NRI does not require any permission to acquire any immovable property in India or transfer any property in India to a Resident citizen or an ROI.

A PIO has some restrictions. He does not require any permission to

1 Purchase a property out of forex.
2 Acquire a property by way of gift from a Resident or from an ROI.
3 Acquire a property by way of inheritance  from an ROI who had acquired such property in accordance with the provisions of the foreign exchange law in force at the time of acquisition by him or FEMA or from a Resident.
4 Sell any immovable property in India  to a Resident.
5 Gift or sell agricultural property to a Resident who is a citizen of India.
6 Gift or sell a residential or commercial property in India to a Resident or  an ROI.

Repatriation of Capital : In the event of sale of immovable property  by an ROI, the AD may allow repatriation of the sale proceeds outside India, provided:
1 The immovable property was acquired by the ROI in accordance with the provisions of the foreign exchange law in force at the time of acquisition by him or FEMA.
2 The sale takes place after 3 years from the date of acquisition of such immovable property or from the date of payment of final instalment of consideration for its acquisition, whichever is later.
3 The amount to be repatriated does not exceed the amount paid for acquisition of the immovable property in forex and
4 In the case of residential property, the repatriation of sale proceeds is restricted to not more than two such properties. There is no restriction on the repatriation of number of commercial properties.


FERA needed the purchaser of the property to inform RBI in Form IPI-7. FEMA has dropped this requirement altogether.

All situations not falling in the category of the general permissions as stated above, including requests for acquisition of agricultural land by any ROI or a foreign national may be made to The Chief General Manager, Reserve Bank of India, Central Office, Exchange Control Department, Foreign Investment Division (III), Mumbai 400 001.

Repatriation of Income : ROIs can freely rent out their immovable property, whether purchased through application of forex or otherwise, without seeking any permission from the RBI. The rental income being a current account transaction is repatriable outside India, only if proper tax is paid on the same. The AD is empowered to arrange for such repatriation.


  21: House Purchased in Wife's Name

Purchasing the house in the name of the wife by applying your own funds means that you are using her as a name-lender and this is a 'benami transaction'. This is illegal. The house squarely belongs to you and you will have to treat it as such. It can be made legal by gifting the money to the wife to enable her purchase the property in her own name. But much of its utility is lost because of the clubbing provision which means that the property income will be added to your income for income tax and its value will be added to your wealth for wealth tax.

Nonetheless, there is some slender advantage in giving a gift. The income on income is not clubbable. In other words, once you have paid tax on the income of your wife (through your own funds), it becomes her own asset. Any income earned on this asset is not required to be clubbed in your hands.


  22: House Purchased from Loan

The repayment of loans and the interest paid carry certain tax concessions. For an NRI the tax concessions are meaningless unless he has taxable Indian income. The concessions are not available if you employ your own funds. Therefore, it is always advantageous to take a loan for purchasing a house and invest your own funds gainfully.


  23: Repatriability of Income from House Property

All persons, whether resident in India or outside  India, who are citizens of Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Afghanistan, China, Iran, Nepal or Bhutan, require prior permission of RBI for acquiring or transferring any immovable property in India.

The NRIs/PIOs can freely rent out their immovable property in India without seeking any permission from the Reserve Bank. The rental income being a current account transaction is freely repatriable outside India.

The AD may allow repatriation of the sale proceeds outside India, provided the immovable property was acquired by the PIO or NRI by direct remittances from abroad or through his NRE / FCNR accounts. The sale should take place after 3 years from the date of acquisition of such immovable property or from the date of payment of final instalment of consideration for its acquisition, whichever is later. The amount sought to be repatriated should / does not exceed the amount of forex applied for its acquisition. In the case of residential property, the repatriation of sale proceeds is restricted to not more than two such properties.


  24: Foreign Nationals Working in India

Foreign nationals of foreign origin as well as persons of Indian origin with foreign passport who have taken up residence in India temporarily on account of their employment, profession or other activity (irrespective of its duration) with the intention of retiring eventually to a foreign country, fall under the category, 'foreign nationals not permanently resident in India'. If the period of engagement of such a person is up to 3 months, he should hold any valid visa such as employment, business, tourist, etc. whereas a valid employment visa is necessary for higher periods.

Salaries to the employees deputed by foreign companies to their Indian offices may be directly paid abroad to the extent of 75% of the net salary (after-tax on full salary) and balance may be paid in India. [Notification No. GSR 103(E) dt 22.1.01].

If the entire salary is paid in India, ADs are permitted to allow such an individual to make remittances for family maintenance, etc., up to 75% of his income or net salary (i.e., after deduction of contribution to PF, etc., and taxes) provided he makes an application (Form-A2) together with a statement (Form-EFT in duplicate) and 'No Objection Certificate' from the income-tax authorities indicating the remittable amount. Even higher remittances may be allowed if the employee is in receipt of perquisites such as free housing, conveyance and medical facilities and his family (wife and children) is resident outside India.

When the foreign national eventually retires and leaves India, all his current assets such as savings from salary, dividend, interest, commission, provident fund balance, sale proceeds of personal effects, etc., can be repatriated in full. Same rule is applicable to pension from India received in future. In addition, he will also be allowed to repatriate his Indian assets of a capital nature such as sale proceeds of investments, up to a limit of Rs. 10 lakhs at the time of retirement and upto Rs. 5 lakhs annually thereafter. For this purpose, the entire family will be considered as a single unit. However, RBI permission for the repatriation is necessary (Form-RFN). Same facility is available to foreign-born widows of Indian nationals who desire to go back (Form-EMG).

Strangely, it appears that such a person is not allowed to have an FCNR account in India since he has become ipso-facto, a Resident in India.

 

  25: PIO Card is not much useful

When the PIO card scheme was introduced, many NRIs who had taken foreign citizenship were excited about the anticipated benefits such as a visa free entry and indefinite stay, more opportunities of investment and possibly work and similar apparent benefits. Now, in retrospect, one wonders about its real utility. The PIO card looks just like a 20 year multiple entry visa and adds no additional value. All that at considerably extra cost of  Rs. 15,000 per adult and Rs. 7,500 per minor. Until June '02, the rates were much steeper at $1,000 and $500 respectively. 

So what then are the real benefits of the PIO card? Why should anyone go for it instead of much cheaper long-term multiple entry visas? Can one still not freely hold and sell property in India without PIO cards? Can one not inherit ancestral property and later dispose it, if he so wished? Can this money not be repatriated totally or partly? Can one not live in India indefinitely, say upon retirement? What about children applying for PIO cards?

The PIO card has become more useless after the advent of FEMA which has many more liberalised provisions.


  26: Stock options

ESOP or sweat equity allotted or transferred by the employer free of cost or at concessional rates was considered as a perquisite taxable in the year in which the option is exercised. Such stocks are normally granted with a lock-in period, which on vesting, entitled the employee to get shares allotted at a pre-determined price. If the employee resigns during this lock-in, there will be no vesting.  This value was taken as the difference between the fair market value and amount actually paid. Thankfully, FA00 has clarified that this will not be treated as a perk any more. Consequently, when the employee exercises the option by paying for it, the cost of acquisition will be taken as the amount actually paid by him. Eventually, when he sells the shares, the provisions of tax on capital gains will be attracted. Normally, the cost of these shares is so high that an employee finds it difficult to pay the cost. In such situations, the sale and the exercise of the option is effected on the same day and the cost of acquisition is paid out of the sale proceeds.

All this is also applicable to stock options offered by a foreign parent company to employees of its Indian subsidiary even when the transfer takes place 'on behalf of' an employee.

The right to accept is understandably not transferable. As and when you sell the shares or transfer them (to your parents through the gift channel) you will be liable to the tax on capital gains. Nomination is a different story. The shares would be transferred in the name of your parents after your death. This transfer does not attract any tax (or stamp duty for the transfer).


  27: Life Insurance & Repatriability

If you decide to pay the premium in the future, it is necessary to file with LIC a special form giving the details, among other things, of your NRE bank account through which you will be paying the premium. The survival benefits should be credited to the same bank account through which you have paid the premium. However, your bank will hold this amount either in your NRO account or in suspense. You will have to obtain a certificate from the bank declaring the veracity of the premium payments through the account and then apply to RBI for permission to repatriate the amount. When you receive the permission, the bank will credit the amount to your NRE account. Thereafter, you can take the money abroad, if you wish to do so.

God! Quite complicated indeed!! In the first place, why does LIC require a certificate from the bank when it has all the necessary details with it? Then again, why should you need any special permission from RBI every time you receive the survival benefit, leave alone the maturity proceeds.

In the case of the death of the policy holder, the proceeds are not repatriable if the nominee happens to be a Resident. This is understandable. But an NRI nominee has to go through the same process as mentioned above and obtain RBI permission. I feel that this is unreasonable. The bereaved nominee may not even know the existence of such a policy and the bank details.


  28: Exchange Risk
The risks are of 2 types :
1 Rupee becoming weaker vis-a-vis the dollar. There is no protection against this, unless you invest in FCNR. However, in my opinion, the Indian Rupee is slated to become stronger in foreseeable future, thanks to the various liberalisation measures taken by the government. While making this observation, I have only one apprehension. The government proposes but the bureaucrat disposes.
2 The loss of opportunity of earning higher returns from the NRE / FCNR accounts is also a risk and this is the most cognisable one. I personally find that many of the NRIs suffer from the fear of the unknown risk of the Rupee slipping heavily and the banks going bankrupt.

Now, let us turn to the risk of ' loss of opportunity to earn higher returns'. NRE offers around 8.5%  a deposit of more than 3 years. If you reject the opportunity and go in for FCNR, you can earn at most 3.90% (These are ICICI Bank rates, prevailing on 30.5.02). 

Rs. 49.01 deposited @ 8.5% will grow to Rs. 73.69 in 5 years and US$1 grows to US$ 1.2108 during the same period. The conclusion is, if you feel that the Rupee will quote at higher than Rs. 60.86 after
5 years, go for FCNR; otherwise, NRE is a good parking place.

This compares NRE with FCNR. FCNR provides protection against exchange risk whereas NRE does not. If you keep the money abroad, you will be lucky to earn even 4%. Remember you are interested in safety of the highest order.

It is your money and it is you who have to make a choice. Forget, history. It may not repeat itself.

This compares NRE with FCNR. You may as well invest in non-repatriable avenues and earn higher returns.

       

  29: Casual Approach

I am sorry if I am hurting you but I feel that you are treating your investments casually. Please realise that your strategy is dependent upon several factors such as your current income and also that of the members of your family, current investments, age, future requirements of liquidity, your risk appetite and several other factors. There cannot be a thumb rule. With this casual approach, you are not only hurting yourself but your wife and children.


  30: Forex Availability to Residents

Though NRIs returning to India after a continuous stay of one year are allowed keep their foreign assets abroad, it is injurious to do so for two reasons. One, Indian interest rates, even in the falling rate regime, are far higher than those available abroad and two, RBI permits more than sufficient funds for specific needs of all the Residents, inclusive of the permanently returned to India NRIs.

A careful examination of the amount of forex available for specific purposes will surely make one realise that there is no need to sacrifice even a small portion of income on investible funds just for maintaining its repatriability.

The following is a list of the limits up to which forex is made available to Residents for various purposes: :

Purpose
US$
Business Travel Quota (BTQ)  25,000 per business trip
Private Visits   5,000 per calendar year
Immigration 5,000 per person.
Employment Abroad   5,000 per person.
Gifts or donations 5,000 in any one year per beneficiary.
Maintenance of close relatives   5,000 per year per recipient.
Medical treatment and check up    Amount recommended by doctor or hospital abroad for the treatment
Study in Foreign Country   30,000 per academic year or estimates from the institution abroad, whichever is higher.
Brokerage to agents abroad for sale of residential flats / commercial plots in India 5% of the forex sent into India.
         

  31: Foreigners & FE

As per Regulation 4(2 & 3), a citizen of foreign state, not being a citizen of Nepal or Bhutan or a PIO, who

1 has retired from an employment in India, or
2 has inherited the assets from an ROI who held assets in India when he was a Resident or inherited from a Resident, or
3 is a widow ROI and has inherited assets of her deceased husband who was an Indian citizen resident in India may remit an amount, not exceeding Rs. 20 lakhs per calendar year, on production of ---
A Documentary evidence in support of acquisition of assets by the remitter.
B A tax clearance / NOC from the income tax authority for the remittance.
C For arriving at annual ceiling of remittance, the funds representing sale proceeds of shares and immovable property owned or held by the citizen of foreign state on repatriation basis in accordance with the FEMR (Acquisition and transfer of immovable property in India) and FEMR (Transfer of Indian security by a person resident outside India) shall not be included.
It is necessary to make the remittance of all installments through the same AD.
D Had come to India for studies / training and has completed it, may remit the balance available in his account, provided such balance represents funds derived out of remittances received from abroad through normal banking channels or rupee proceeds of FE brought by such person and sold to an AD or out of stipend / scholarship received from the government or any organisation in India. An AD may effect such remittances.
E Foreign nationals on temporary visit are allowed to take back the unspent amount against Encashment Certificate or Bank Certificate in Form-ECF and Form - BCI respectively and forex tendered at the customs counter while going abroad.

Take care. Both the ECF and BCI are valid for 3 months for reconversion of Rupees into forex in all the cases, temporary visits or otherwise.

No Rupee loans can be granted to foreign nationals or liaison offices of foreign companies except for personal purposes such as purchase of household articles up to a maximum of Rs. 5 lakhs on the total borrowings of the depositor and his dependents from all the banks.

       

  32: Prudent to File Returns in India

There is no legal obligation to file tax returns unless the income chargeable to tax exceeds the minimum tax threshold of Rs. 50,000. This is so whether you are an NRI or a Resident. The only exception is 1-by-6 scheme which requires an individual to file returns if he passes any 1 of the 6 specified conditions. This 1-by-6 scheme is not applicable to NRIs. Therefore, most of the NRIs are not required to file the returns.

Nevertheless, it is prudent to file the returns to ensure continuity after the individual returns to India.

As I have repeatedly asserted, though it is not necessary to file the returns if your taxable income, after claiming the exemptions u/s 10 and deductions u/s 80L, 80G, 80D, etc., is less than the threshold of Rs. 50,000 it is advisable to file the returns for the sake of continuity when the NRI eventually returns to India. It is necessary to file the returns even if your tax liability becomes nil after taking advantage of the tax rebates.


  33: Tax Haven

Thanks to the process of liberalisation a new avenue serving as panacea for all investment problems has emerged in the form of pure-growth, open-ended, debt-based schemes of UTI / MFS. Being pure-growth, these are so much tax efficient that you can earn as much take-home (= tax-free) income as Rs. 5 lakhs on a corpus of Rs. 50 lakhs. Being open-ended, these behave like an SB account where you can deposit and withdraw at will. The only difference is that the banks take 5 minutes to effect an withdrawal but MFs take 5 working days or less. Being debt-based, the safety of the capital as well as the income (around 10%+ at this juncture) is implicitly certain but not explicitly assured.

   Share your suggestion , feedback or query with us at nri@icicibank.com  


Copyright 2002. ICICI Bank NRI Services
Terms and Conditions | Disclaimer